Discipleship Is Not A Do-It-Yourself Project by Rob Haynes

Maybe you are like me and enjoy trying Do-It-Yourself (DIY) projects. I enjoy the challenge of tackling carpentry, mechanical, or other such projects. The proliferation of DIY information online, particularly on YouTube, makes it even easier to gain confidence to try new tasks. However, not everything, including Christian Discipleship, is a DIY Project. 

The Limits of DIY Faith

There is a saying I grew up with that goes something like this, “I know just enough about [that particular subject] to be dangerous.” That means I have enough knowledge of that particular thing to get started in it, but not enough to do it well, completely, or safely. We see this, to a degree, in the account of the Rich Young Ruler (see Luke 18, for example). A young man, someone of some prominence in the community, comes to Jesus and asks, “What must I do to inherit eternal life?” 

What he was saying was: “What’s the minimum I need to do to get to Heaven?” The two have a dialogue about the teaching of Scriptures. The young man says that he knows the Scriptures. Jesus doesn’t argue with this. Where it falls apart is where Jesus tells the man to follow his teachings—all of them. And at this, the young man goes away sad.

Ouch. But, let’s be honest—haven’t many of us asked the same question?

The Rich Young Ruler was looking for a DIY project of faith. Give me what I need to know, and I’ll take care of it myself. I have some knowledge of the life of faith, but don’t ask me to do the stuff I don’t want to do. The Bible’s teaching is that it is not enough to just say, “Oh, yeah. That’s a good idea. Everyone else should do that.” Jesus expects each of us to be transformed by the Truth, and to live it out.

Mere recognition is not the same as trust. Sincere belief does not always equal surrender.

The Role of Community in Discipleship

John Wesley cautioned against this sort of misunderstanding. In his 1748 “An Account of the People Called Methodists”, Wesley cautioned those who keep the Bible on the shelf—even if we affirm every teaching in it—if we do not allow it to transform us. Having all the right answers, like the Rich Young Ruler, Wesley said, was a “Slender part of religion.” He went on to say that we need to have the right attitude and actions towards, and about God, as well.

That means that we need to DO what the Bible says. We call that discipleship. At its best, discipleship is not a DIY project. Elsewhere on this platform, we have discussed Wesley’s emphasis on Class Meetings and Band Meetings as a mechanism for Christians to come together to work out their salvation as they grow in holiness of heart and life. Those articles talk about much of the “how,” but I would like to emphasize some of the “why” here. 

When I teach about Class Meetings, I sometimes hear people tell me that it will never work for them. They, and the people in their communities, are too private. They would never share their Christian journey with others. Part of that, I think, has to do with a misunderstanding about the idea of a “personal relationship with Jesus.” The terminology of a “personal relationship” was a response to some parts of the church where people let the institutional Church do the thinking for them. Yes, we need a personal—everyone of us involved—relationship with Jesus. But that doesn’t mean that it is private. With gratitude to the late Eugene Peterson, let me see if I can illustrate.

People love polls. We see them on the news all the time. Let’s imagine that we heard a report from a trusted pollster who made a definitive statement about a new Netflix series. People would nod and say “Yes, I will watch that series because of what that pollster said.” But what if we learned that the pollster had only consulted one person, and that the person had only seen 10 minutes of the first episode of the series. We would rightly be suspicious of the recommendation.

But this is exactly the kind of evidence that too many Christians would accept as the FINAL truth about many, much more important matters like faith, forgiveness, God’s will in the world, eternal salvation, or the latest issue where culture and faith intersect. And the only person they have consulted is themselves. And the only experience they used to make this evaluation is the most recent 10 minutes.

Listening to a Living Word

These are complicated issues. How do we do what the Bible says, in our world today? To answer that, we need to look at the Bible and its role today. The Bible begins with “God Spoke…” The Bible is an account of how God spoke to and through people throughout history. We see that God speaks to the prophets, to shepherds, to the disciples, and others. The Bible is the record of that. However, the last writings we have are almost 2,000 years old. Is God still speaking? Since God spoke in the beginning, and throughout the record of his work, why would we think he quit there? You see, the Bible is not just a book that was once spoken, it is a book that is now speaking. It is best heard in community.

God gives us one another—other brothers and sisters in the community of faith—and the history of experiences by our biblical ancestors. The lessons of Abraham, Moses, David, Esther, Peter, Paul, and the others are still available to us. However, one who refuses to learn those lessons, in the community of other Christian disciples, is like refusing to remember to move your thumb from the top of the nail when you swing that hammer. Refusing to move it again means you will get hurt again. That is when DIY projects get dangerous.

Discipleship involves listening to the Bible that still speaks, and to do so in the community of others who are doing the same. This moves faith beyond a simple acknowledgement that we should do the right thing by living as followers of Christ. Doing less than that can be dangerous for you, and for others.